| Home | Open Account | Help | 343 users online |
|
Member Login
Discussion
Media SharingHostingLibrarySite Info |
Western Railroad Discussion > Hump and retarder questions?Date: November 02, 2026 11:11PM Hump and retarder questions? Author: JasonCNW First I want to say welcome back TO, this is my first post since the upgrade and it's great to be back. Thanks also to our webmaster for working hard doing the upgrades.
Now to my question and I have to be vague about the details as the investigation is ongoing. But this one is directed to those who have or do work at a Hump Yard. Is it possible or even likely that foreign material from a freight car leaking or blowing off the top or even caked to the wheels to cause the retarder to malfunction and send the cars into the bowl tracks at unsafe speeds? And too if somehow leaking product such as grain or powdered cement or any type of commodity like that would or could get into the retarder how much would it take of said product to cause the retarder to malfunction? Curious minds wish to know, thank you for any info. JC Posted from Android Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 11/02/2026 11:12PM by JasonCNW. Date: November 03, 2026 03:17AM Re: Hump and retarder questions? Author: doc1057 Cars can have oil or other lubricants on the wheels lead to overspeed and overrun when humping. Where I have seen this is on tank cars used for hauling oil or tallow. Somehow, material got on the wheels when the car was loaded, leading later to problems when humping. It's probably not super common, but it does happen. Whether other materials can cause this, I don't know.
Date: November 03, 2026 10:15AM Re: Hump and retarder questions? Author: cewherry In the days when friction bearing cars were 'normal', SP car men at Taylor yard in Los Angeles would inspect cars
prior to traveling over the 'hump'. The inspection included a look into the journal boxes to check for oil levels. Those cars needing oil would have their journal-box lids left in the 'open' (raised) position as a sign the journal was in need of oil. As the cars were being 'humped', another carman (one on each side of the track) would 'squirt' oil, using a pressurized hose, into the journal housing. Inevitably, some of the oil could end up on the face of wheels, making its way outward, to the rim, where the upcoming retarders would squeeze---or try to squeeze the wheel in an effort to try to slow the car-- often with less than desired results. Charlie Date: November 03, 2026 03:29PM Re: Hump and retarder questions? Author: Englewood The retarder is probably not malfunctioning.
It is applying the proper amount of resistance for a car that weight going the required distance. The foreign material on the wheel has changed the resistance required and the system has no way of knowing of the change. Date: November 03, 2026 05:19PM Re: Hump and retarder questions? Author: webmaster cewherry Wrote:
------------------------------------------------------- > cars needing oil would have their journal-box lids > left in the 'open' (raised) position as a sign the > journal was in need > of oil. Here is a video from our library taken at Taylor that shows this very event happening. Skip ahead to 5:25 in the film: https://www.trainorders.com/discussion/read.php?11,1362154,1362154#1362154 Todd Clark Canyon Country, CA Trainorders.com Date: November 04, 2026 12:15PM Re: Hump and retarder questions? Author: railstiesballast I recall an incident in SP's Houston Hump Yard, Englewood, a few miles east of downtown, where a car had picked up some viscocity extender (think STP) on its wheels.
That car could not be slowed and had a violent impact, breaking a flamable car open leading to fireworks. Inquiring minds asked why a flamable car was in the bowl.....and no satiisfactory explanations were found. The SP could do dumb things before the UP took over. Date: November 04, 2026 02:43PM Re: Hump and retarder questions? Author: OHRY As I was taught by an old yardmaster, "kid this is the Allentown hump not the Allentown shove."
railstiesballast Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > I recall an incident in SP's Houston Hump Yard, > Englewood, a few miles east of downtown, where a > car had picked up some viscocity extender (think > STP) on its wheels. > That car could not be slowed and had a violent > impact, breaking a flamable car open leading to > fireworks. > Inquiring minds asked why a flamable car was in > the bowl.....and no satiisfactory explanations > were found. > The SP could do dumb things before the UP took > over. Posted from Android |