Home Open Account Help 488 users online

Passenger Trains > Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains


Pages:  [ 1 ][ 2 ] [ Next ]
Current Page:1 of 2


Date: October 30, 2026 04:31PM
Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: milepost20

A Summary from the International Railway Journal of 10/29:

"The California High-Speed Rail Authority (CHSRA) has awarded Siemens a $281.7m contract 
to supply three Velaro Novo 354km/h(220 mph) trains. CHSRA’s board voted unanimously to approve 
the deal on October 28, that also includes a $284.1m 10-year full maintenance contract 
and $206.3m for escalation, taxes and other charges. The fleet contract also includes 
an option to purchase up to 19 more trainsets at $62.1m each."

That awards Siemens with a current contract total of $772.1m.  The original plan was for
six trains for testing purposes now reduced to these three.  The option for 19 further trains 
would add another $1.2 billion.  Start of revenue service between Merced and Bakersfield is  
planned for 2034.




Date: October 30, 2026 05:07PM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: Eggenberger

milepost20 Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> A Summary from the International Railway Journal
> of 10/29:
>
> "The California High-Speed Rail Authority (CHSRA)
> has awarded Siemens a $281.7m contract 
> to supply three Velaro Novo 354km/h(220 mph)
> trains. CHSRA’s board voted unanimously to
> approve 
> the deal on October 28, that also includes a
> $284.1m 10-year full maintenance contract 
> and $206.3m for escalation, taxes and other
> charges. The fleet contract also includes 
> an option to purchase up to 19 more trainsets at
> $62.1m each."
>
> That awards Siemens with a current contract total
> of $772.1m.  The original plan was for
> six trains for testing purposes now reduced to
> these three.  The option for 19 further trains 
> would add another $1.2 billion.  Start of revenue
> service between Merced and Bakersfield is  
> planned for 2034.

What is the meaning of "Gold Plated" in the title?



Date: October 30, 2026 06:35PM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: milepost20

Eggenberger Wrote:
> What is the meaning of "Gold Plated" in the title?

.In the context of the rail industry would refer to new trains and infrastructure 
that are considered as overengineered and excessively expensive.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 10/31/2026 12:32PM by milepost20.



Date: October 31, 2026 04:17AM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: jp1822

milepost20 Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
>Start of revenue
> service between Merced and Bakersfield is  
> planned for 2034.

That's a perfect corridor for high speed train service! Those trains will be packed!!! What a joke.........



Date: October 31, 2026 01:50PM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: TAW

jp1822 Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> milepost20 Wrote:
> -------------------------------------------------------
> >Start of revenue
> > service between Merced and Bakersfield is  
> > planned for 2034.
>
> That's a perfect corridor for high speed train
> service! Those trains will be packed!!! What a
> joke.........

I'd like a reservation, 12th of Never, biz class, from Nowhere to Nowhere Else please.

TAW



Date: October 31, 2026 05:10PM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: 462pacific

Buying rolling stock even before the track is layed. That's optimisim for
sure. The three locos on order represent almost half of the original
cost for the whole line. I vote NO!



Date: October 31, 2026 05:27PM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: SAAP

milepost20 Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Eggenberger Wrote:
> > What is the meaning of "Gold Plated" in the title?
>
> .In the context of the rail industry would refer to new trains and infrastructure that are considered as overengineered and excessively expensive.
>
Correct. It's also a professional project management term that applies to any industry. 



Date: October 31, 2026 09:28PM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: ProAmtrak

Nice but will it ever get built?



Date: October 31, 2026 09:54PM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: PHall

462pacific Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Buying rolling stock even before the track is
> layed. That's optimisim for
> sure. The three locos on order represent almost
> half of the original
> cost for the whole line. I vote NO!


Track laying should start soon, they have been stockpiling ballast and track materials in preperation.



Date: November 01, 2026 12:37AM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: cph

I thought I saw a recent picture of ties (no rails yet) being laid  on a viaduct somewhere, but I don't remember where. 
(Assuming the picture is real in the first place...)



Date: November 01, 2026 03:58AM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: will74205

Taiwan HSR signed the contract to purchase 12 N700ST from Japan consortium for ~63$million each 12-car trainsets in 2023, so the price for California HSR trainset is in line with internaional standards.



Date: November 01, 2026 05:53AM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: hsr_fan

ProAmtrak Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Nice but will it ever get built?

I think we'll see Bakersfield to Fresno or Merced.  Too much is built already for that to get shelved I suspect.  I think they're looking at single track with passing sidings to save money though for the initial build, even though the right of way is built for two tracks. San Fran to LA - maybe if we get political leadership that makes infrastructure a priority but I don't count on being around to see it.



Date: November 01, 2026 07:21AM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: cchan006

cph Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> I thought I saw a recent picture of ties (no rails
> yet) being laid  on a viaduct somewhere, but I
> don't remember where. 

If I remember correctly, the pile of ties were near Wasco (snarky smile).

> (Assuming the picture is real in the first place...)

I'd say that the ties were piled there, backed up by witnesses here on TO. Timing of the piles showing up was suspicious, because there was a fight for federal funding going on at the time.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 11/01/2026 07:23AM by cchan006.



Date: November 01, 2026 07:37AM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: cchan006

462pacific Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Buying rolling stock even before the track is layed.

Depends on how the project is managed. Might not be "optimism" in other parts of the world where the organizations involved already demonstrated competency, transparency - i.e. finished projects with trains running carrying passengers.

> The three locos on order represent almost half of
> the original cost for the whole line.

You're counting the chickens before the eggs have hatched. The costs don't mean anything. All I see is a computer graphics of Siemens Velaro Novo train set. I remember clearly the computer graphics of Japan's Class 700 in past meanginless propaganda from CA HSR.



Date: November 01, 2026 08:08AM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: cchan006

will74205 Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Taiwan HSR signed the contract to purchase 12
> N700ST from Japan consortium for ~63$million each
> 12-car trainsets in 2023, so the price for
> California HSR trainset is in line with
> internaional standards.

We need to stop arguing costs about a project that's nowhere close to being finished.

Taiwan HSR had its own challenges, which required 2 years of intensive testing before revenue service (carrying passengers) in 2007. Before that, 8 years to construct 220 miles. Current and original train set is a modified Class 700, its technolgy already proven in 1997, 8 years before the construction was finished in 2005.

N700ST's technology is already proven, too, modified from the N700S, which was already running 5 years ago (see my report in International Discussions).

Siemens Velaro Novo? "Announced" in 2018, yet still not in service. Hope more TO members are waking up to in-your-face propaganda, where we are busy arguing the "future" and "costs" that are merely ideas.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 11/01/2026 08:33AM by cchan006.



Date: November 01, 2026 08:23AM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: ts1457

hsr_fan Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> I think we'll see Bakersfield to Fresno or
> Merced. 

The farebox recovery on that will be spectacularly low.  After a drain like that, if CAHSR has not progressed connecting segments very far,  the whole project will fold.



Date: November 01, 2026 08:54AM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: cchan006

ts1457 Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> The farebox recovery on that will be spectacularly
> low.  After a drain like that, if CAHSR has not
> progressed connecting segments very far,  the
> whole project will fold.

Many successful HSR projects around the world did the difficult and expensive work of overcoming geography and established urban development (building into city centers, instead of around them) to make the business model work: ridership --> revenue. CA HSR, even at its best totally chickened out (CACO, or California Always Chickens Out?).

I don't think the project will fold. CA HSR is a convenient scam, regardless of cost. You're giving too much credit, thinking that they will "fold" to prevent further financial losses. In the end, you just have to laugh at people promoting it, as actually riding the service is nowhere close to reality.



Date: November 01, 2026 09:34AM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: ts1457

cchan006 Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> I don't think the project will fold. CA HSR is a
> convenient scam, regardless of cost. You're giving
> too much credit, thinking that they will "fold" to
> prevent further financial losses. In the end, you
> just have to laugh at people promoting it, as
> actually riding the service is nowhere close to
> reality.

You are probably correct. However, the intensity of the spotlight on them will be increasing, so we might eventually have a breaking point.



Date: November 02, 2026 02:22PM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: JunkTrain

Why did the CEO quit?



Date: November 02, 2026 02:46PM
Re: Calif. HSRA's Gold Plated Siemens Trains
Author: PacificElectric1961

Democrat Govenor candidate Becerra has stated he will replaced existing leadership if elected. I'm sure the current CEO decided to speed up the process. 



Pages:  [ 1 ][ 2 ] [ Next ]
Current Page:1 of 2


[ Share Thread on Facebook ] [ Search ] [ Start a New Thread ] [ Back to Thread List ] [ <Newer ] [ Older> ] 
Page created in 0.0333 seconds