| Home | Open Account | Help | 539 users online |
|
Member Login
Discussion
Media SharingHostingLibrarySite Info |
Steam & Excursion > From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1Date: December 28, 2012 03:13PM From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: OKTrainboys How could the PRR scrapped every last one....did one even come close to making it?
Lots of high dollar materials in these loco's....certainly the whole was worth more than the parts...right? Date: December 28, 2012 03:33PM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: tomstp Pennsy was already in financial difficulies and every scrap dollar counted.
Date: December 28, 2012 05:39PM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: PERichardson In my opinion, even worse was the NYC not saving a Hudson and Niagara. And let's not get into the razing of Penn Station.
Date: December 28, 2012 09:27PM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: rcall31060 masterphots Wrote:
------------------------------------------------------- > In my opinion, even worse was the NYC not saving a > Hudson and Niagara. And let's not get into the > razing of Penn Station. That could be said of so many engines and RR facilities. Alas, some people have no sense of historic value. Sad. Bob Callahan Monticello, IN Date: December 28, 2012 09:57PM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: SD45X Need to read Classic Trains Holiday 2012 issue. Fresh look at PRR's T1.
Date: December 28, 2012 10:29PM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: Realist SD45X Wrote:
------------------------------------------------------- > Need to read Classic Trains Holiday 2012 issue. > Fresh look at PRR's T1. Wherein you will see that PRR DID reuse some parts. Date: December 29, 2012 06:23AM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: Bob3985 masterphots Wrote:
------------------------------------------------------- > In my opinion, even worse was the NYC not saving a > Hudson and Niagara. And let's not get into the > razing of Penn Station. I believe it can be said that every railroad had locomotives that we wish at least one was saved to be an example of their power but that didn't happen very often, unfortunately. Bob Krieger Cheyenne, WY Date: December 29, 2012 06:36AM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: RuleG rcall31060 Wrote:
------------------------------------------------------- > masterphots Wrote: > -------------------------------------------------- > ----- > > In my opinion, even worse was the NYC not saving > a > > Hudson and Niagara. And let's not get into the > > razing of Penn Station. > > That could be said of so many engines and RR > facilities. Alas, some people have no sense of > historic value. Sad. As a glass half full kind of guy guy, I would point out that several PRR steam locomotives have been saved and the 100th anniversary of NYC's Grand Central Terminal will be observed in 2013. Date: December 29, 2012 03:45PM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: HotWater As a long time "steam guy", plus I'm into real high horsepower locomotives, I sure wouldn't mind trying to fire a T1 in excursion service. Having discussed the T1's many times during conversations with the late Vernon Smith, and his son Charles Smith (who still has all his dad's note books and technical files), they surely were fantastic pieces of motive power, and could handle passenger trains to unbelievable speeds.
Damned shame one wasn't saved! Date: December 29, 2012 08:25PM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: OKTrainboys Jack, yes, it is this first and account stuff that is really fascinating....those loco's were designed to pull passenger trains with a trailing load of 850 to 900 tons at 100mph ALL DAY LONG...and did just that.
Date: December 29, 2012 09:19PM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: ChooChooDennis I highly recommend the "Steam Glory 3" by Kalmbach issue that has that fantastic article. By David R. Stephenson, the article is called "Pennsy's T1 Reassessed." It restores respect to the brilliant, unique design it was.
My favorite story though, is by John R. Crosby in "Trains" magazine called "Last Chance." The year was 1993 or 4 I believe. However the most intriguing idea is the rumor I heard that the T-1's did speeds up to 140MPH! Clearly that would make them the fastest steam locomotives in the world. Sadly we will never know. Date: December 29, 2012 10:58PM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: rcall31060 ChooChooDennis Wrote:
------------------------------------------------------- > I highly recommend the "Steam Glory 3" by Kalmbach > issue that has that fantastic article. By David R. > Stephenson, the article is called "Pennsy's T1 > Reassessed." It restores respect to the brilliant, > unique design it was. > > My favorite story though, is by John R. Crosby in > "Trains" magazine called "Last Chance." The year > was 1993 or 4 I believe. You're absolutely right about Dave Stephenson's article in "Steam Glory 3". BTW, David R, Stephenson is TO Member "feltonhill". His posts, on the Steam Forum, have done much to advance my meager knowledge of steam locomotion. There have been so many myths and outright falsehoods perpetuated about the T1. It's about damn time, that the record is being set straight on these unique and revolutionary locomotives. David is just the man for the job. Several years ago, knowing of Dave's access to actual PRR records and his desire to debunk the myths and falsehoods surrounding the T1, I sent David a PM, asking him if he might, for the sake of history and posterity, write a book on the subject. For various (and understandable) reasons, he declined. Now, much to my delight and everlasting gratitude, he's done the next best thing and given us a thoughtful, objective, well researched, no-holds-barred, unvarnished assessment, of these fantastic engines and the circumstances under which they were operated and maintained (or NOT maintained). Those of us, who value the truth, owe David a debt of gratitude, for his effort. Now, if he could give us an article on the Pennsy's Q2........ To your point about John R. Crosby's (RIP) article about his last opportunity to fire a T1, you are spot-on. It is a GREAT read, for anyone who wants to know what a T1 could do, with a good crew in the cab. I highly recommend it. Bob Callahan Monticello, IN Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 12/29/2012 11:01PM by rcall31060. Date: December 30, 2012 06:02AM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: HotWater ChooChooDennis Wrote:
------------------------------------------------------- > However the most intriguing idea is the rumor I > heard that the T-1's did speeds up to 140MPH! > Clearly that would make them the fastest steam > locomotives in the world. Sadly we will never > know. Not rumor! Charlie Smith still has his father's "timing books", from when Vernon Smith worked for Franklin Railway Supply (manufacturer of the poppet valve system). Mr Smith had to "Go out and ride those damned things, and find out what the crews are doing to them!". Thus, Mr. Smith was in the cabs of many of the T1s at speeds well over 120 MPH, between Chicago, Fort Wayne, and eastern Ohio! As a result of all that high speed, the chain drive poppet valve gear assembly was being "over stressed", and Franklin "denied the warranty claims" from the PRR Mechanical Dept. Date: December 30, 2012 07:34AM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: Frisco1522 The only two things I've ever heard against the engines were that they could be ornery and ungainly with the long wheelbase and that they were filthy to fire and run. I've seen movies of them going east at Washington Park, IL (across the river from St. Louis) going like the hammers of hell.
I went downtown to the RR Y with my Dad to a meeting when I was about 11 and sat at one of the upper floor windows facing the St Louis Union Station throat tracks and watched trains come and go and TRRA switching. A T1 arrived with a train from the east and was backing her train into the station. I'm sure the engineer used up his vocabulary as she would get on a puzzle switch and one engine would break loose and he would nurse her through it then the other engine would break loose. I don't believe the engines were losers, I think PRR with it's "Standard RR of the World" attitude sinking so much money into so many of them started the financial wheels turning and that caused more trouble than the engines. Like Sinatra, they always did it their way, right or wrong. Date: December 30, 2012 07:54AM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: OKTrainboys Don, given what you just said about the two separate engine sets loosing it on the throat puzzle tracks, do you think it could have been a good idea to install separate throttles on each engine set that could be operated in concert or separately? Or maybe a way to "notch up or down" the steam admission to each engine set independently......
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 12/30/2012 08:07AM by OKTrainboys. Date: December 30, 2012 08:34AM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: I1sa I think if the T1 would have been more successful and survived in use up into the mid 50's, one might have made it into the Northumberland collection, though I believe the turntable there was only 100', not 110' like Crestline's so that might have posed some storage issues and would have sat outside in the elements. Much like why probably the J1 never survived, not that it was really a 100% Pennsy design, but from what I read they were not really too feasible east of their territory.
I read that by the end of 1949 that all the T1's were dropped from service, but I have seen a few photos of them in mid 1950 still in service so I do not know how accurate that is? They only made 52 of them, perhaps if they made 500+ one would have survived, it even amazes me they only kept one Decapod, they made nearly 600 of them. Date: December 30, 2012 08:39AM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: ts1457 ChooChooDennis Wrote:
------------------------------------------------------- > My favorite story though, is by John R. Crosby in > "Trains" magazine called "Last Chance." The year > was 1993 or 4 I believe. August 1993. One of my favorite stories, too. Mr. Crosby and his engineer drew a T1 on a 15 car mail and express train after most passenger trains west of Harrisburg had been dieselized in 1948. The engineer decided that it would be his last chance to see what a T1 would do. He managed to get the speed to 120 mph on the Van Wert to Ft. Wayne leg of the trip. Date: December 30, 2012 09:01AM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: HotWater OKTrainboys Wrote:
------------------------------------------------------- > Don, given what you just said about the two > separate engine sets loosing it on the throat > puzzle tracks, do you think it could have been a > good idea to install separate throttles on each > engine set that could be operated in concert or > separately? Or maybe a way to "notch up or down" > the steam admission to each engine set > independently...... Personally, I don't think that would work ON THE PRR, what with their lack of maintenance, and their lack of engine-men training, as pointed out in the Classic Trains "STEAM GLORY 3" story on the T1s. The few VERY best Engineers and Firemen could really do wonders with the T1 and Q2 class locomotives, but those few "good crews" were apparently few and far between. Date: December 30, 2012 11:00AM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: rcall31060 I1sa Wrote:
------------------------------------------------------- > They only made 52 of them, perhaps if they made > 500+ one would have survived, it even amazes me > they only kept one Decapod, they made nearly 600 > of them. IIRC, there were two I1's saved. One at Nothumberland and one outside a Westinghouse(?) plant somewhere in PA. Bob Callahan Monticello, IN Date: December 30, 2012 11:08AM Re: From anyone's memory vault....PRR T1 Author: RLcabin I1sa Wrote:
------------------------------------------------------- > I read that by the end of 1949 that all the T1's > were dropped from service, but I have seen a few > photos of them in mid 1950 still in service so I > do not know how accurate that is? 130 road passenger units were delivered between 1945 and 1949, and that was enough to just about kick the T1's (and other steam) off Pennsy's through east-west passenger trains. Purchases slowed down for a couple of years after that, with only 10 road passenger units (E8's)delivered in 1950 and 18 in 1951. 100 units were delivered in 1952 (E8's and FP7's) and that was the real end of any T1 use or other steam on long-haul passenger trains. So from 1949 through 1951 there was still some use for the T1's; a sort of twilight period if you will. I recently found a record of train movements for UF Tower which controlled the east throat of PRR's Pittsburgh Union Station. The date is July 9, 1949. It shows T1's on 4 mail & express trains, 3 eastbound troop trains, the eastbound Trail Blazer and the westbound Pennsylvanian. (I would guess the T1's were substituting for failed diesels on these last 2 trains.) Keep in mind that passenger train traffic in those days was subject to frequent surges, with lots of special trains and extra sections of regular trains operated during busy periods. So in this "twilight" period, some T1's would have been kept busy handling these extra trains, together with some mail & express traffic, plus emergency use in case of diesel failures. Regards, Rich Tower |