Model Railroading > Decoder Selection Opinions - Proto 1000 DL-109

Hey there. I'm looking into installing my first decoders into two Proto 1000 DL-109 locomotives I recently purchased.

I believe I understand the basics of installing the decoder, but the first thing I need to do, of course, is to decide which decoder to use. I have looked at some of the WOWsound decoders, which I like for their KeepAlive function and such. However, I'm not sure if that type of decoder is advisable for this locomotive. I'd like to have sound in the locomotives, as well, so I'm not looking for only a decoder, but also a speaker.

Does anyone have any advice for which decoder to select, or any advice on installing DCC in this type of locomotive?

Thanks,
Dreadnought

I believe the DL-109 was powered by dual 539T Alco prime movers. This limits your choices to either Soundtraxx or LokSound. Both make good 539T soundfiles, but personally I believe Soundtraxx version is a little better. My Soundtraxx 539T equipped RS1's sound awesome while my LokSound 539T equipped S2 does not sound quite as good.

I'll present a contrasting opinion. To my ears the Loksound Alco 539T is the best. In its latest version with the Full Throttle feature it is amazing.

KG

Loksound has a sound file specifically for the DL-109. It simulates the sound of the dual prime movers. It would be your best choice.

KG

DCC is 30+ year old technology. Take a look at RailPro. Twice the capability, half the cost, and none of the complexity.

So which Railpro sound decoder do you recommend for the DL-109?



TwinStar Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> DCC is 30+ year old technology. Take a look at
> RailPro. Twice the capability, half the cost, and
> none of the complexity.